Showing posts with label technology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label technology. Show all posts

Thursday, April 1, 2010

No Class 12.5: April 1, 2010

The VPN Culture?

The article by Manuel Castells (year 2000) that I referenced in the last entry, Toward a Sociology of the Network Society, and some of Denis’s works have been in my sights during the last few days, along with last week’s TEDs.

Let me begin here by again quoting the Castells paper: “I [Castells] understand technology... as material culture – that is, as a socially embedded process, not as an exogenous factor affecting society.” Sounds familiar. Technology as a process? Our tools shaping us? This is getting old already. Yet, if it is a central idea recognized universally by leading thinkers of our time, then it must be proverbial in nature. “We shape our tools, then our tools shape us” (Marshall McLuhan). Castells defined in the paper a new type of society that depends on information technology and electronic hypertext, is global in scope, but sheds independent sovereignties – the nation state dissolved. He called it the network society. No longer, he suggests, will relationships (personal or professional) be built upon physical spaces (places). Instead, they will emerge in “the space of flows.” “The global city, in the strict analytical sense, is not any particular city. ... [it] is a network of noncontiguous territories, reunited around the task of managing globalism by networks that transcend locality” (Castells). One more Castells quote to underscore the new reality: “Interactive networks are the components of [the new] social structure, as well as the agencies of social change.”

What’s the meaning of all of this? Stating the obvious, our world has changed. We live on-line more and more. The VPN or social networking sites like Facebook are the new spaces of gathering, not necessarily the office or the coffee shop, though they will likely be around indefinitely. Castells’s vision is realistic, especially in light of enterprise efficiency. We need to remember that it was the efficiency equation that made computers a fixture in the business world. Also, the socially pervasive get-the-latest-gadget craze has followed the business efficiency equation of keep up or die. In business, to have the edge on the competition, one needs faster and better tools. The technology and thinking that has shaped business efficiency, or maybe military superiority, has spilled into households and has transformed almost everyone's thinking and behaviour.

What has happened in education to reflect the network society? There has been a lot of talk and attempts have been made to incorporate on-line collaborative and other current electronic tools into the learning space. Successes and failures have been realized, and in those is evidence of an attempt to shift pedagogical thinking, to make “educational technology ... a way of thinking,” as Denis said in his article Educational Technology: A Definition for the 21st Century.

I guess a question that might be asked with regard to educational technology is, “Why really do we afford it?” Is the shift in pedagogy about better learning, or is it about mirroring the business community? Is it about creating virtual learning communities, or is it about adhering to standards? I very much like another quote that comes from the 21st century definition article by Denis. Denis quotes James McKernan (2008) as saying, “a curriculum to be truly educational will lead the student to unanticipated rather than predicted outcomes.” What a powerful statement. Does the technology we are making available in schools afford creative and unanticipated outcomes? I think so. The presence of technology in schools, while mirroring the world of work, does yield unpredictable results (some good, and as we all too well know, some not so). It also helps to create a learning culture alive with many possibilities. Over time, with the help of teachers, students will learn how to build robust VPNs to take full charge of their learning. Young Mike’s scrapbook is already in the form of e-portfolios, and meeting places like Second Life or Facebook transcend space like the holograph of Jessica Yellin. The culture is emerging – it’s already here – but it will take more time to fully transform education. We need to keep working at it, planting good seeds and weeding the garden, so to speak. Commitment and leadership are required. Speaking of which, if you have not read Denis's article Educational Technology and Wikipedia, I recommend it. There needs to be someone authoritative around to be able to distinguish a good plant from a weed. Here's a tool to help us with that.

April 2

Need to add this. Denis concluded his article Writing History with Lightning by saying:
Pedagogy does not exist in a void, but within a cultural context: What should we teach? How do we teach it? Where do we teach it? When do we teach it? Who should do the teaching? The answers to the pedagogic questions clearly lie within the broader conceptualization of the age in which we live.
I was going through my stuff and had noticed a note to blog that quote. I knew I had forgotten something. I think that quote basically sums up this entire post.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Class 5: February 4, 2010

Frames of Reference

During the class, I said a few things about the enframing section of The Question Concerning Technology and read from a paper by David Waddington. I didn't discuss what may be considered an important point or two in that section, so I'll share now what I might have also said.

The enframing is, I think and as I said in class, a frame of reference from which to view the world. It's ironic that Heidegger uses the discipline of physics to make his point because it is in physics that frames of reference abound. It really is interesting in the sense that modern physics is purely theoretical; that is, what is discovered is first put forward through hypothesis, and then from the realm of the unseen, the concealed, comes the proof. When was the last time you saw an atom, let alone a quark? I haven't either, but according to physicists, they are there. Nature has reported to physicists that it is so.

Heidegger said that "because the essence of technology lies in enframing, modern technology must employ exact physical science." His reference to Heisenberg's lecture may be the address Heisenberg gave when accepting the 1933 Nobel Prize for physics - have not been able to verify that yet. I looked at that address; didn't read beyond the first page. Anyway, Heidegger also says that even causality is not the same, that it too has become a "reporting challenged forth." Everything is now coldly calculated and has become ultra utilitarian, physical science supporting all. Not to worry though, the saving power exists.

Moving on, Theoretical Physics (modern physics) is essentially all mathematics. But, like Heidegger said, math existed before technology. Here is where fuzz appears, again. How can technology set-upon math? It doesn’t, unless we’re trying to prove that pi is rational, and then we need a program to run a computer to get to that next decimal place. A program... hmm, I want to talk about that.

Probably everyone in this course has written a computer program. Programming is all about modeling and ordering, an exercise similar to that of Theoretical Physics. Theoretical physicists make models based partially on what has come before, which, when traced back far enough, are built upon direct observation of nature. Those observations were modeled mathematically afterward, not the other way around. Newtonian Physics began with observation, not with math, yet, it did turn into a mathematical physics. No matter. Just imagine that you observe a phenomenon and realize you can model it with an equation. Now begin playing with equations supporting particular phenomena, in the same way Denis was playing with the text/words during class. Let the enframing begin? Play with enough things that you can see and maybe you’ll discover something you can’t. Enough... as I was saying, programming is about modeling and ordering. Not one detail can be missed when composing a program, not one condition overlooked. And while programmers today have sophisticated tools to help create the Windows’ of the world, those tools must meticulously be designed on paper (or in mind) and every possibility thought through before production of them can begin. Early computers would have first begun on paper and all the hardware’s AND, NAND, OR and NOR gates tested by tracing through manually, in the same way we add numbers without a calculator. The computer, actually all modern technology, is nothing short of miraculous. The technology - the techne - behind it is not the laws of physics or chemistry, it’s the reason and creativity that went into combining the scientific laws with pure logic. Programming, actually all engineering design, is a perfect act of enframing. But, it is all grounded in revealing, a process directed by Being (so Heidegger might say). The modern machine, in the generic sense of the word, is a work of art, just like the chalice. Given what I have just said, the essence of technology just might be pure reason, which can be said to be spirit. I read that in a book somewhere years ago, that spirit is pure reason. Hence, the essence of technology is nothing physical, and as Heidegger says, it is an illusion to think so. Spirit, by the way, can be argued to be the essence of Being. So, logical syllogism applied, Being is technology. Yes... so, if technology is Being revealed, then enframing must be a destining because Being does things on its own terms. Having said that, I still believe in free choice, as I said in my handout. But, wouldn't it be something if the choices we make, which we think are free, are actually predestined. That, is on the edge. One last observation regarding revealing, the light from the most distant stars is just starting to hit Earth now. The universe is revealing itself.

Now, if you are not too tired, here’s another idea. How do we challenge-forth learning? What technology – techne – do we use? Denis pointed out that his iPhone challenges him... well, I’ll say preoccupies him. But, he is interested in it... and he is learning. The technology is challenging-forth learning. Something I heard on the radio today struck me. I was listening to The Age of Persuasion on CBC radio one, 990. Host Terry O’Reilly talked about media theorist Neil Postman, saying that he said that when there was only printed materials, people thought in text, in print. They would have also thought in images, and music. Today, people also think in hyper-mode media: websites, TV, smartphone. Designing curricula for all the media of current thought sounds like a good idea.

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Class 4: January 28, 2010

How we use tech...

...quite honestly, depends on us. Of course, you may think, well, is that not the most obvious of the obvious. Yes, perhaps. But, click on the following link and press PLAY, http://fc01.deviantart.com/fs13/f/2007/077/2/e/Animator_vs__Animation_by_alanbecker.swf.
I'd like your feedback on the show. Had you seen it? What does this short film say about technology in education? I'll say more after I post to the confernece on NiceNet.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ok, back from NiceNet conferencing. I found the animation of the stick figure fighting it out with the developer really neat. There is a fair amount of work that goes into making such a show. It was sent to my dad through a video club, Winnipeg Amateur Moviemakers.

So, getting to how technology is used in the classroom. A video like the Animator vs. Animation could be done as a Flash project, if one teaches that. It can definitely serve as an exemplar of creativity and quality work. Of course, that example speaks to a minority of teachers and students. But the creativity element is universal. Another universal is critical thinking. How should tech be used to develop that? The Maddin film is an excellent example. On NiceNet, all we've done is offer critcal analysis - not negative remarks, but reflections about its meaning. Film is a powerful medium. Did anyone, besides me, watch the CBC series ZeD that ended on 2006? It was on after the late news. It had some very interesting short films and an ethereal kind of music that had groove. I think the short film should be used a lot, as work projects students do. They could create something like Maddin, finding old pictures, mixing them with new, adding their own voice. All to tell a story or make a report (documentary). In a school I worked at a few years ago, a student ran for student council but didn't make a live speech. Instead, he played a video made of him. It was good. He won. I may try the video essay soon. How about a video thesis?

We all know about how we need to handle the internet; but, like James said on NiceNet, there just may be teachers out there who don't know what it means to Google something. These days, I'd say that would be rare, but not impossible. In a nutshell, teach how to search and tell about authoritative sources. I have found guided searches can work well with middle years kids.

One more thing... PREP!! Using tech well requires prep. Those who don't want to make the prep investment probably won't use tech well, if they do at all. There are many ways to effectively use tech in the classroom given today's tools. Computers & peripherals, smartboards, mobiles, TV, radio, films, sound recordings. What am I missing? How about everyone at the high school level taking a computer science course (programming, not Word or Excel)? Creating software certainly can develop great critical thinking skills.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Class 1: January 7, 2010

Technology is/as Art

Technology is/as art. It's a concept that makes sense. I have wrestled with this idea before, and was happy to hear it given attention tonight. I'll work with it here.

I begin by conjecturing that most teachers will acknowledge pedagogical practice as an artform. Now, if that be true and with logical transitivity applied, it can be said that technology is/as pedagogy. Seems quite reasonable.

A paper is available in the JSTOR database titled Ideas of Technology: The Technological Order. It was written by frenchman Jacques Ellul (1962) and translated by a guy named John Wilkinson. Anyway, Ellul describes technology as technique. In fact, the paper says that in his book La Technique, Ellul agrees with H. D. Lasswell's (Lasswell was a professor who wrote quite a bit about technique, so said my Google search about him) definition of technique, which is, "the ensemble of practices by which one uses available resources in order to achieve certain valued ends." That sounds like it could be a definition for an artform.

The techniques which I use in the classroom are practices/procedures/processes applied after consideration is given to a desired end. My (pegagogical) technique, which includes how I discern what is good and not for my students, is an artform (technology is/as pedagogy). My technologies are not just the laptops, data projectors, tablets or the software (tools) available for me to use, but the ways I use them.

Going further, the product of technique may also be called art. Technology is/as art, is easily seen when the art is a tool developed thanks to an inventive mind. The computer is the art of the computer engineer, and so is the student the art of the teacher. Hmm. Something doesn't seem right here. Does that make a student a technology? A computer can be used to help get a job done; it is a tool. But is a student a tool? Maybe (context). A student is a learning technology (as we all are). And, students are definitley works of art, works created by many artists.

The idea is technology as technique and technique being an art, hence technology is/as art.